Score: 5 / 5
Some movies were just meant for you. You know? I had that experience once this year with HIM and now, again, with Bring Her Back. Before I finally got to it -- having taken most of the summer off -- I rewatched the Philippou brothers' Talk to Me (2022), which I remember liking but not feeling strongly about. The rewatch changed my opinion, so I'll likely have to revise my old review, and made me quite excited for this film, about which I knew absolutely nothing. The title suggests something similar to their previous venture, involving a dead female and some attempts at reviving her, right? Sure. But Bring Her Back is so much more.
I used to say that the new Big Three in new inventive horror -- Jordan Peele, Ari Aster, and Robert Eggers -- started with an intensely focused initial film and delivered sophomores much broader and weirder and angrier. And the Philippous do the same here, crafting a film so mysterious and intense and strange that I felt like my sofa was vibrating beneath me. Rarely have I been this uncomfortable and unsure in a movie in my own living room. Even with its well-lit and brightly colored visuals, a far cry indeed from Talk to Me, which threw me from the start. And not even because it's wholly unpredictable, though I confess to having had no idea whatsoever what was in store for our protagonists, stepsiblings Andy and Piper, played by equally excellent Billy Barratt and Sora Wong.
A delicious Sally Hawkins reigns over this story as Laura, an eccentric and delightful new foster mother for two orphans. She's a free spirit and a former social worker and she's one of the most emotionally terrifying creatures I've ever seen on screen. She's got ulterior motives, you see, and her explicit preference for one of her new charges should raise your hackles. Their little family -- including Laura's other stepson, who is mute, after the untimely and tragic death of Laura's biological daughter -- has a unique dynamic I found endlessly fascinating in a film founded on the believability of their unbelievable relationship.
I won't say more for fear of spoiling it. This is an exceptional film to go into totally cold. It suggestively pulls from multiple horror subgenres, with a heady result of nasty influences meant to keep you off-kilter and anxious. A few moments are sure to have you shaking your head and muttering "what?!" through your wince. Anyone familiar with emotional abuse, take heed: this will trigger you badly, and once it starts, it doesn't stop; there are similar vibes in Resurrection and Alice, Darling which are similarly upsetting. And that's not the whole hog, either: I can only imagine how stressful it would be to have been in the foster system and now witness two endangered kids desperate for help and being institutionally unable to get help for their very real and very urgent situation.