Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Undertone (2026)

Score: 2 / 5

Loss of hearing is a minor trope in survival horror, when home invaders or alien monsters are drawn with murderous intent to the sounds someone makes. Like the protagonists in Hush, Don't Breathe, and A Quiet Place, the audience is invited to lean in and remain silent, often holding our breath as we, too, fear detection. This storytelling device is rarely used inversely, though, when we desperately need to hear something in order to understand the plot itself. A notable example -- the only one I can recall offhand -- is The Vast of Night, in which kids use switchboards and phones and radios to learn about an active encounter of the third kind. When A24 announced a new horror film based on aural frisson, I was intrigued to say the least.

Undertone, helmed by a debut director in Ian Tuason, is a devilish little nightmare of a film that seeks to capitalize on its sound design. Set in the home of young woman Evy (Nina Kiri, The Handmaid's Tale), caring for her dying mother, the story follows her experiences of taking a break from being a nursemaid to podcast with her remote friend Justin (Adam DiMarco, The White Lotus). They're a sort of gender-copied Mulder and Scully; their "Undertone Podcast" dives into spooky shenanigans and paranormal activities, wherein Justin advocates and Evy skepticizes. So when Justin receives an email with ten audio recordings from a married couple who start hearing things in their house (it's all a la Paranormal Activity), he introduces it to Evy as their next mystery to unfold on air. Do we call podcasts "on air"? Someone help me out, I'm not a listener.

I say the film seeks to capitalize on its sound design because of this very premise. Once the characters -- of whom we only ever see Evy -- dive into these surely virus-ridden email attachments, I expected some killer sound design meant to disorient and terrify us. Oddly enough, it feels like the filmmakers either didn't know how to do it or thought their material was more interesting narratively. Sure, there are some weird sounds and creepy voices akin to a possessed Regan MacNeil, but nothing particularly scary about sound itself carries the film. Once I wondered if the film would take a turn like in Talk Radio (1988) or Black Christmas (1974) and have the audio messages somehow be recorded inside the house or by a stalker lying in wait. Because other than that potentiality, not much of interest happens with the otherwise striking decision to limit the protagonist (and, thus, the audience) to the desk of a podcaster. 

Then again, not much of interest happens in the film anyway. A rather boring story, to my mind, cuddles more than grapples its primary theme of grief, lulling us into a stupor with cinematography that rarely earns its painfully slow pace. On par with the speed of Skinamarink, this doesn't even have the added pleasures of sheer weirdness and evocative visual nostalgia. As -- spoiler alert, I guess -- they listen through the recordings and reveal some demonic entity in the files, Evy begins to lose her mind and her world fractures. Admittedly the film surprised me a bit in Evy's character, who is more complex than you might at first suppose; she's pregnant and likely considering abortion, her mother is catatonic and dying just upstairs, and the house is littered with religious imagery. Fun themes of faith and death flit in and out, though the screenplay -- also by Tuason -- doesn't really do anything with them. And the plot itself is largely derived from other works like Last Shift (2014) and Malum (2023).

That's not to say it's not entertaining, of course! Just disappointing, especially when the film so easily could have been designed with more aesthetic cohesion. Enhance the soundscape, for starters, and try minimizing the visuals. Develop a more original story that hinges on sound and make us work to understand what's happening. And for goodness' sake, if you're going to use a demon's name, make it recognizable or at least spell it out at some point. I couldn't make much sense of the dialogue in this film. It also didn't help that Justin's character is terribly written; his dialogue often makes little sense and serves only as annoyance. The performance, too, felt off, and I wondered repeatedly if they recast his role. 

I'll go so far as to say it might be the first film that would be better viewing at home as long as you're using surround sound or a pair of excellent headphones; that might improve my opinion on a rewatch. But between a familiar but cool premise and some ugly filmmaking, Undertone simply fails to make much of an impression. 

It's perhaps telling, as a final note, that Blumhouse has already named Tuason as the director of their upcoming Paranormal Activity reboot (or whatever it will be). You can see clear elements of that in play here, with slow, sweeping looks into the dark recesses of Evy's house and compelling use of negative space and stillness in blocking. One expects to see a similar approach to new entries in the famed found footage franchise, though it feels more contrived and artistic in the current age of "elevated" horror. If Undertone is an indication of Tuason's sole aesthetic, we'll be getting more of this unfortunately typical style soon in the franchise made famous for its clever, understated horror. 

No comments:

Post a Comment