Score: 3.5 / 5
A revenge thriller that uses body horror? It may not be the most original idea, but it's a welcome entry in the superhero genre; I've enjoyed the Sony-produced Marvel films about antiheroes for this reason, but this time we're getting it from DC. Their newly rebooted cinematic universe has so far only included Superman and Supergirl, making Clayface easily the most unexpected and exciting choice of the new franchise. He's not the most familiar character to me personally -- I vaguely remember him from the Gotham series on FOX in the last decade -- so this film works quite well as an origin story. Unfortunately, because of that, the film also feels too predictable and safe, despite its icky body horror.
Matt Hagen (a dedicated and electrifying Tom Rhys Harries) is the newest leading male in Hollywood: handsome, doing the press circuit, and getting nominated for his first Oscar. In his pride and arrogance, he goes out to celebrate and ends up dancing with the sexiest woman in one of Gotham's crime-ridden clubs. After taking her home, ignoring the advice from his best friend that she's a regular of a local kingpin, he gets caught by said underworld boss. The criminal takes vengeance by carving up Matt's pretty face and paying off any attempts of legal action. Matt's life is over: professionally and romantically, he's doomed, to say nothing of the medical debt he accrues through multiple restorative surgeries that leave him intact but numb and debilitatingly scarred.
The screenplay by notable writers Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini (The Two Faces of January, Drive, Snow White and the Huntsman) focuses in perhaps too tightly to Matt's predicament and desperation to get his own life back. It's a convenient approach that elides much reference to his material limitations and allows Matt to do whatever he wants without much at stake. Granted, his life gets fully taken from him in a few brutal swings: his embezzling manager (Eddie Marsan) and opportunistic best friend (Joshua James) take Matt's professional life and make it their own after Matt's agent dumps him. In a stroke of luck -- and not unlike what we've seen in many superhero movies -- Matt discovers a fringe scientist who has developed nanocell tech to heal grievous scars and wounds. Anyone with any sense knows how this is going to go, even with Naomi Ackie giving an earnest and surprisingly emotionally resonant performance.
Seemingly returned to normal, Matt makes a surprise triumphant appearance at a red carpet event. Before long, though, his heightened emotional state causes his face to melt and he hurries back to the lab to inject himself with a major dose of the healing nano-goo. The good doctor objects but is overruled, and Matt becomes a sort of Cronenbergian protagonist a la The Fly, allowing his newfound powers of shapeshifting to empower him to take revenge on everyone who has wronged him. In this, it's as satisfying as any revenge thriller, with the added benefit of some gruesome and nasty body horror.
Unfortunately, the film hints a few times at more complex directions it could have explored before reverting to its basic and predictable path. I'd have liked a bit more of the internal psychology of Matt explored: was he always a murderous sociopath, or is this new? Is he being controlled by the cure, an embodied AI-fueled possession like in Upgrade or even The Hands of Orlac? Is his reluctant doctor to blame, like a Victor Frankenstein, or part of a shadowy organization like in The Substance? Not so. Instead, we waste time with the basic plot contrivance of a lone cop (Max Minghella) tracing the series of murders to Matt and building a case against him.
I felt invited to participate in the film's characters' considerations of just how much Matt is to blame for his killing streak, but by the film's final act, he became increasingly difficult to understand or believe. Arguably it's because his sins have changed him into a monster, but I wanted him to have really earned it as he turns on his only friends in increasingly cruel ways. It just felt convenient that he became such a villain. If this film had taken on the more complex psychological character-driven approach, like Joker, notably, Matt would feel more realized as a compelling antihero while earning our attention. Instead, the film relies on its concept and spectacle to arouse our interest. To be fair, its practical effects are pretty awesome and the gore is considerable indeed. But for a film meant to take place in Gotham, it feels generally too sanitized, too standard, and too safe to be especially memorable.
![]()