Friday, November 20, 2026

Supergirl (2026)

Score: 2 / 5

As superhero movies -- having dominated the box office consistently for a quarter of a century now -- finally become risky studio ventures, the "new" DCEU doesn't seem to know what to do with its latest titles. The second title under James Gunn's studio leadership does exactly as I feared it might, even under the direction of excellent filmmaker Craig Gillespie (Fright Night, I, Tonya, and Cruella). That is to say that it feels like a James Gunn movie once removed. Breakneck, snide, crude, and ugly, more concerned with its production design and soundtrack than with its characters and themes.

Admittedly, I can't speak to the plot of this film beyond its premise. It makes no sense, even having seen the other DC films leading up to it, though apparently only Superman matters anymore. Kara Zor-El (Milly Alcock) is a nomadic party girl who has fled Earth -- and her cousin, Superman (David Corenswet), who keeps trying to connect with her -- and spends her time hovering around red stars so that she can get and stay intoxicated and get in bar brawls. Like her cousin, the light of a yellow star gives her godlike powers and prevents her from inebriation. She lives with Krypto, a small white dog sidekick who serves as her MacGuffin in this film. He's shot with a poisonous arrow by a brigand (a creepy Matthias Schoenaerts) and has three days before the toxin will kill him. Kara has to hunt down the brigand to get the antidote he keeps on his person.

The brigand also butchered a family -- dramatized in the bleak opening scene -- whose lone survivor, a girl, has vowed revenge. So Kara takes with her Ruthye (Eve Ridley), a grim and determined young woman whose single-minded determination makes a striking foil to Kara's aimlessness. Unfortunately, their yin-and-yang dance throughout the film serves more to hide their vulnerabilities and intrigues. Instead of diving into the devastation that has made these women the heroes they become, we spend far too much time trying to establish them as heroes based on superficial qualities alone. Considering that this movie comes almost a decade after the feminist celebration that was Wonder Woman, and five years since the excellent Supergirl series ended, we deserved a hell of a lot better.

Kara -- and Alcock, I'm sorry to say -- is grating for the film's entire runtime, overacting as a foolish wastrel. It doesn't help that she (and we) are dragged through a string of increasingly superfluous, unimaginative encounters that make up the contrived plot. I get that Kara in this movie is meant to be unlikable, but she's just miserable the whole time; even her biggest danger, poisoned by a green sun, is only the result of her own foolhardiness. Sure, Alcock gets to fight plenty, but few of these sequences are staged well. Overwrought production design, though looking great, disguises messy fight choreography and melodramatic fights that are edited so rapidly I often found it hard to watch. The cinematography isn't a boon, either, as most scenes are so dark as to be indiscernible on screen; when there is light, it's garish and harsh, with contrasting fluorescent hues from single locations, making everything else an opaque umbra. 

While I'm glad to see a superhero film that doesn't require world-destroying villains and large teams of allies to save the day, I can't help but wish for more finesse, thought, and beauty in a film that, by definition, should inspire. And without those stakes, the ridiculous amount of CGI in this film is wholly uncalled for; even Krypton is awful to watch, rendered in ugly CGI that fails to convince us of any sense of grounded reality. Even when the reliably wacky Jason Momoa pops into this film, he can't relieve its crippling sense of wasted opportunities; he himself is doing a strange Kiss-meets-Sons of Anarchy thing that feels ripped from a different film entirely. One hopes that, if the DCEU continues, Gunn will allow other artists to take more charge and guide this mess out of his clearly restrictive hands.

Toy Story 5 (2026)

Score 4 / 5

Just when I thought the franchise had rung its death knell, Andrew Stanton came to the rescue. Toy Story 5 reinvigorates the series with a hilarious and heartwarming return to classic form, resisting easy cliches and nostalgia in favor of perhaps unnecessary timeliness that nevertheless makes this film both riveting and memorable. 

I knew I was in for an emotional wringer when, after the prologue, the film proper opens on cowgirl Jessie (Joan Cusack) in her iconic, idyllic memory of Emily. Piano dripping with pathos thrums us into her theme song -- which never fails to make me weep -- as she reminisces on being abandoned so many years ago. Interestingly, this opening also reminded me of Toy Story 3, arguably the peak of this franchise and where most of us hoped it would end; the stultifying anxiety of being forgotten and abandoned, rendered irrelevant due to age or what have you. In this new film, however, we're treated to a slightly shifted anxiety: what happens to the real world -- real feelings, real friends, real connection, real fun -- when tech takes over?

Before you roll your eyes at me, give this movie a watch. Keying into Jessie as the main character this time around, Stanton and co-writer Kenna Harris give us an original viewpoint into this fabulous world while also making critical commentary on the state of youth and community in an age of "devices" and screens. We open with Bonnie, the Andy successor of this latter part of the series, who is seemingly the only kid in her neighborhood who still plays with toys. Everyone else has tablets, phones, and computers, especially the hot new toy, Lilypad. When Bonnie heartbreakingly asks her parents one day why nobody will be her friend, they make the tough decision to get her a Lilypad. She's thrilled, of course, but almost immediately loses her ability to function in the real world.

When Lily (Greta Lee) is confronted by Jessie and Bonnie's other toys, she defends her value by making "friends" with some local girls online. In a horrifying turn of events, Bonnie goes to her first sleepover eager to play, only to have the four girls mindlessly engaged with their own devices. This is where the story kicks into gear: as Jessie and Buckeye try to intervene and help Bonnie, they get separated and taken across town to -- guess where? -- the old address of Emily, as written inside Jessie's chaps in faded marker. Emily doesn't live there anymore, but a young girl named Blaze does; Blaze, living on a farm, loves horses and feels more a part of the real world than the digital world. Their journey back to Bonnie will take them through multiple households and lots of discarded and forgotten toys, many of whom learn life lessons with Jessie during their quest for relevance.

If this all sounds a bit preachy, I suppose it is. The screenplay has several on-the-nose moments that might feel groan-inducing if they didn't ring so very, sadly, true. Thankfully, Cusack's earnestness shines through and makes Jessie's sermons both palatable and often compelling. She's bolstered by a great voice cast, as usual, with a few newcomers like Lee and even Conan O'Brien; old favorites are given lovely moments to shine, and the filmmakers nicely balance the tone between sweet and silly as they similarly balance old and new voices and ideas. Lee has an especially cool role that she handles nicely: she starts as a villainous character and turns rather easily into a regretful anti-villain, if we can use such a term. Her arc of reconciliation is remarkable.

That's not to say it's all perfect; frankly, nothing in this franchise has ever fit that superlative for me. I'm very happy this film was brave enough not to focus on Woody and Buzz, though they pop in for a significant subplot that feels more like Abbott and Costello than like the characters we've grown to love. I did like, however, how, there's some clever gender play between Buzz and Jessie, whose romance finally climaxes in this film: Buzz is an awkward, simpering lovestruck mess while Jessie takes control of the situation and risks it all to save Bonnie from tech. There's an even more bizarre subplot with a bunch of Buzzes who survived a shipment wreck and seek Star Command; there are some cool ideas they offer the screenplay, like interactivity with nature and what amounts to involuntary narcolepsy when humans are around -- apparently it's not a choice for toys to play dead? -- but it feels a bit too distracting and for disappointingly little payoff in the end.

Perhaps that's not fair. They climax with an admittedly rapturous charge across the field with Blaze's toy horse collection. 

In Disney and Pixar's proven and masterful hands, the film is gorgeous to behold and a fantastically fun time. I'll have to watch again to get all the little tidbits of comedy, as they are deployed rapid-fire and I often laughed and missed their follow-up one-liners. While it plays with some cool ideas, it never really capitalizes on them, preferring instead to play things safe and ensure its raw emotional moments really land with audiences of all ages. Preachy or not, I cried multiple times while watching, and that's not nothing when this is the same franchise that gave us Lightyear.

Lilypad, a frog-like tablet, is centered in the poster in front of the toys, who look at her confusing and shocked.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Wildwood (2026)

Score: 5 / 5

In our age of increased tech, AI slop, hallucinations, depression, and general ennui about what exactly being human constitutes, Travis Knight's Wildwood is a clarion call of joy, ingenuity, art, nature, and humanity. I'm still riding the high of this viewing experience, and it's been over a week. I can scarcely wait to enter the forest again.

Easily the biggest and most important stop-motion film ever made, Wildwood feels like if the creators of  Kubo and the Two Strings decided to tackle The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. Which is, actually, pretty damn close to accurate. Laika, the studio behind Kubo as well as Coraline and ParaNorman, is arguably my favorite animation company -- yes, even above Disney, who y'all know I'm a slut for -- and it returns in glorious fashion to adapt the 2011 novel of the same name by Colin Meloy. Apparently Meloy wrote a trilogy, and I'm now eager to get my hands on them. Not necessarily because the material here is wholly original (what is, these days?), but because it's so beautifully conceived.

Much as in Lewis's famed Narnia series, the story concerns Prue (Peyton Elizabeth Lee), a Portland teen whose parents warn her to never take her baby brother Mac outside. Of course, in full Grimm style, she does, and almost immediately Mac is abducted by a murder of crows, who whisk him away to the "Impassable Wilderness" bordering Portland. There is more than a hint of magical realism here as we're spirited into a full-blown fantasy realm literally across the river from urbanity, a place of dense fog, enormous trees, supernatural creatures, and magic-wielders with axes to grind. This is a dangerous place, forbidden to regular Portlanders, yet this teen and her friend Curtis (Jacob Tremblay) navigate it with something between compulsory purpose and earnest, awed adventure.

It's immediately apparent, of course, but in case you're inexplicably reluctant to get on its wavelength, Wildwood is more visually and artistically beautiful and expansive than anything animated you've ever seen. I really really won't spoil this film for you, except to say that by the time of its final battle -- in full Lord of the Rings style -- I was so blown away by the sheer amount of physically created miniatures and set pieces and weapons and characters and costumes that I forgot it was all handmade. And it's all so flawlessly rendered, touched up by VFX yet always recognizable as practical, that I almost forgot they weren't humans at all. 

It helps, too, that it's evocative of something we rarely see in film at all. The Pacific Northwest, with its unique folktales and sense of being on the edge of pure wilderness, is an amazing, brilliant setting for this kind of escapist fantasy that is simultaneously about a very real, increasingly polluted and technological world. When our young heroes meet, first, a squad of talking coyotes in uniform, my jaw hit the ground. Frankly, I hadn't done my homework, and thus had no idea what I was in for. They're part of an army for Alexandra (Carey Mulligan), a wicked dowager governess determined to claim a baby boy and... well, the plot is arguably archetypal, yet it unfolds with such authentic inspiration and organic revelation that I cannot hardly criticize it.

Suffice to say that Wildwood has many more themes on its mind that mere allegory or escapism. Desperation and grief and loss, caring for the young and helpless, the nature of madness and living off the grid; it's all there, and then some. I found perhaps the most compelling theme to be that of how we respond to tribulation and adversity; I guess it's a spoiler, but sometimes we simply don't succeed, so dealing with failure has to be part of our experience as "heroes." Indeed, sometimes life simply is what it is -- hard -- and yet we continue to live a life that doesn't collapse and strain and despair. Sometimes beauty is found in the failure, in the messy, and in the incomplete.

Which is saying a lot, because this film feels shockingly complete, especially knowing how long it took to produce and knowing that it's the first part of a trilogy. One wonders if and when the two sequels will be released, and one hopes earnestly that Laika and director Travis Knight continue to build this amazing world, especially now that they have so many of the saved production materials. Even apart from its physical impressiveness, there's something to be said about the old-school genre-inclusive approach to epic storytelling: comedy, horror, bildungsroman, fantasy, adventure, folk tale -- it's all there in spades. Keep in mind, parents, that this is PG-13 for a reason, including some surprisingly adult language and moments of violence and fear. If you're a fan of voice casts for animated films, there's a lot here to please you too! In supporting roles of varying screen time, we have Mahershala Ali, Angela Bassett, Jemaine Clement, Tom Waits, Amandla Stenberg, Charlie Day, Richard E. Grant, and even Blythe Danner. Even in bit parts, these feel so perfectly cast and deeply lived-in that I had trouble pinpointing some of them. 

Not Danner, though. Obviously.

The film is somewhat exhausting, to be fair, even in its roughly two hours of runtime. There is simply so much movie in this movie that I felt fatigued by the time of the climactic battle. Thankfully, that was a me problem, not the film's, and its ability to rouse me into its intense and explosive final act is a testament to its profound strength. It's perhaps the best example of truly sublime filmmaking I've seen in years: a perfectly calibrated blend of that which is beautiful and that which is terrible. I'll need repeat viewings to more adequately critique its plot and characters, its crowded themes and its evocative aesthetic choices. But as a moment of pure entertainment in the realm of high art, Wildwood is one of the most important films of the year and one of the best, regardless of your metric. In fact, it's not dissimilar from The Wild Robot, and if you need more of these vibes to get you through the next animation drought, I'd recommend that one for sure.

A murder of crows curves up and behind the primary protagonist and antagonist, originating from the centrally placed manor in the forest. The image is infused with a warm yellow on the left and an icy blue on the right.

Wicker (2026)

Score: 4.5 / 5

Fairy tales for adults are rare enough, but when they hit, it's good. Tonally similar to something like Chocolat, the new romantic comedy-drama Wicker fits the bill in deeply satisfying and sometimes surprising moves. 

Set in some unspecified but apparently late medieval village, the story concerns the local outcast, a lonely Fisherwoman, played to perfection by Olivia Colman. Her occupational odor and lack of finer habiliments render her the target of scorn and derision, perhaps most vociferously by the village women, most of whom are married. In this place, marriage is what gives a woman her social worth, and the Fisherwoman is happy to be single; this makes her a weirdo and a threat, not unlike Belle in Beauty and the Beast, and so she must be constantly ridiculed in order to maintain social order. Yet despite her rational ideas about marriage and independence, the Fisherwoman eventually relents and goes to the local Basket Weaver for help. You'll notice, in the credits if not the film proper, that characters are identified by their social role or occupation, not by name.

The Basket Weaver -- played by Peter Dinklage as a sort of narrator of this fairy tale -- is also apparently a man of magic. The Fisherwoman's request, that he make her a husband, is honored, and in a mere month, she shows up to the chapel to meet her husband at their marriage ceremony. Indeed, he's there, played by Alexander Skarsgard in a remarkably understated performance that allows some amazing practical effects to take primary focus. Their relationship feels bespoke (as, of course, it is), and the screenplay allows them to awkwardly fumble with each other before settling into an earned and mutually fulfilling partnership. While the villagers scoff and wonder, their attitudes indeed soften as they see the unusual joy and beauty bloom in someone they had so reviled. After all, the Fisherwoman didn't even allow her Wicker Husband to clasp a golden collar around her neck (the film's symbolic version of a wedding ring). What if married couples did so out of love and mutuality, not obligation and expectation? What if men and women were equals and we just let people blossom in their own bliss?

The film shifts, then, in its second half, to the villagers themselves and how they respond to this strange and lovely new couple in their midst. The Baker and Bottlewasher and Tailor of the village are all married, and their relationships with their wives -- led by Elizabeth Debicki -- change dramatically over the course of the film. Some want more sex, some want better sex; some want equality at home and at work; one even wants her own baby made of wicker, which of course causes more than some raised brows, considering who its father might be.

I don't want to spoil the delightful turns of this story and its incredible screenplay by directors Alex Huston Fischer and Eleanor Wilson, but it's worth every minute of screen time and maybe more. Uproariously funny, it's also deeply heartfelt and human in its comforting quest to find identity and love and purpose. This sort of fable-like world is always endearing on screen -- I thought more than once of something like The Princess Bride or Willow -- and it's helped by some smart commentary on gender, small town drama, commitment, occupation, and of course free will. It's also helped by a delightful cast, from Dinklage with his three or four philosophic voiceover monologues to Richard E. Grant in a bit part as a drunk doctor. Naughty jokes, amazing practical effects from Weta Workshop, and beautiful production design in costumes, props, and sets makes the whole experience transportive and transcendent. I can't wait to rewatch.

You Can See Everything (2026)

Score: 5 / 5

The most important film of the year, You Can See Everything does wholly new things with the documentary form. Any attempt to render this viewing experience into prose will lessen its physical and psychic impact, so be warned. If you want a singular cinematic rapture this year, go to your nearest cinema while this is still available on the big screen.

And I'll start sharing my thoughts by admitting that I was wrong. 

Not about Nathan Fielder, of whom I knew literally nothing, and not about Lance Oppenheim, whose Primetime is possibly my favorite film of 2026. No, I was baffled by why anyone thought yet another documentary about Elizabeth Holmes was even necessary, much less for a studio like A24 to back it. HBO's The Inventor (2019) already exists, along with books, podcasts, interviews, write-ups, and of course the dramatized miniseries The Dropout. Surely we could learn nothing new about her or her crimes, bizarre and inexplicable as they are. Why, then, do we need to exist with her in her own home in the month before she begins her 11-year prison sentence?

Watch, and learn, young grasshopper.

Yet Fielder himself is truly the main character in this film; its main themes not about family or loss or even crime, but rather about the nature of reality and those strange people who live on a different wavelength than the rest of us. Fielder's hero's quest launches him on a search for truth, or at least some kind of truth. He's no journalist, and ethics become a primary concern as things evolve between him and his hosts. Hosts, I say, because apparently Holmes had reached out to A24 specifically -- a suspect choice, for several reasons -- to invite a filmmaker to come live with her and film the experience. How much could possibly be true under such circumstances? Yet, later, when it's revealed that, during their initial meeting, Fielder straight up asked for some compensation if the film does well, the filmmakers' reactions are almost exaggeratedly shocked that he would ask for such a reasonable thing. Again, they're not journalists, and that's not where the shady ethics stop in this film.

Fielder often approaches scenes with Holmes and her husband Billy with a deadpan, sardonic expression; I've learned since that this tends to be his persona, but here I found it distracting more than humorous. This despite uproarious laughter from the audience in each screening I've attended, which is understandable but feels a bit tasteless to me, considering her impending separation from family. Yet the reaction is undeniable at certain moments, such as when Billy clearly wants to be filmed while showered; the full frontal is always nice, but here it feels especially insidious as we begin to learn more about Fielder's hosts. Not particularly potent, Fielder tends to stalk and skulk around like a serial killer in the making; often leering out of doorways or creeping from his car window, he's shown to be a physically unpleasant presence and, increasingly, an unreliable narrator. By film's end, he's done some overtly unethical things in pursuit of whatever truth he seeks, to the point of changing his own dramatization to be less impactful and to the further point of lying to us -- his audience -- about going into the water on the beach with Holmes. Is he emphasizing Holmes's hypnotic power and showing how fallible he himself is? Then again, is he just making a point to us not to blindly believe anything, even what we see in his documentary?

The three main characters, together, make the film's dynamics oddly like a horror-comedy, scored as they are by an ominous musical undergird. Billy is monstrous and awful. He lords over the film like a despotic villain, so egregiously controlling every moment he's nearby that the film can't help but show his behind-the-scenes "directing." He domineers the home, even roughly taking over beating her eggs because she's not doing it right (whatever that even means). If Holmes says something that could be taken as less-than-innocent, Billy halts the proceedings and makes necessary adjustments. Despite their claims of transparency, he repeatedly separates himself from the film crew and takes Holmes along so they can reassess their tactics. This latter is where the film's title presumably comes from: after some initial engagement, Billy takes off down the beach, where Holmes soon texts Fielder that he and his crew "can see everything," an oddly removed moment of what sounds like blanket consent. It's hard to accept that this isn't determined by Billy, but then, it is Holmes texting it. Later in the film, when Holmes is in prison, Billy uses her name and social media platform to pose as Holmes herself; they claim it's with her full consent, but what he posts is a far cry from how she sounds.

Which brings us to Holmes herself. While the film formally seems angled to get us to see Billy for the absuive manipulator and narcissist that he clearly is, it does so by somewhat softening Holmes's impact. One wonders the extent to which Fielder was beguiled by the cipher of a woman who never seems fully present or aware. Granted, she's trying to coddle her children and partner in the limited time she has before incarceration, so who's to say any of us would be fully in command of our faculties? Yet along with her near-constant rocking of a baby, she too is putting up a lot of smoke and mirrors. She comes off -- and I think this is crucial and perhaps the most disturbing part of this film -- remarkably well here. Surprisingly little time is devoted to her life, her crimes, and her interior life, so don't go into a screening expecting a tell-all.

Rather, if we see the real Holmes at all -- whoever that is, and however we might determine when we see it -- it is through a glass darkly, at best. She's often framed with a beatific smile in warm amber light, a consummate mother and housewife holding fast to her idealism and bizarre sense of hope. She wants her company to continue and thrive, pivoting as they are now to deepfakes and AI (which elicited such a loud "no fucking way" from me in the theater that other people chimed in to repeat variations), and she won't give an inch regarding her claims to innocence. Though I wish a hard-hitting journalist was called in instead, Fielder occasionally fires a blunt question at her, and her abilities of evasion and blatant lying is as admirable as it is terrifying. 

And that gets at the heart of this movie, and why her story is so compelling in general. Her entire basis for "not guilty" is semantics -- her intended technology is possible, just not happening yet -- and her desperation to hold on to hope and intention and purpose is relatable. Which leads us to perhaps the most important question of all: what is her goal in allowing these documentarians into her private life during perhaps the most important and vulnerable month of her life? To be humanized in the public eye? If so, I think she succeeds in disturbingly effective form, playing the filmmakers and audience like a harp. She plucks the strings with nary a fumble, allowing Billy to come off like a Mad Men antagonist and Fielder to seem like a simpering fool, all the while gazing into space like Cate Blanchett's Galadriel, a preternatural, wide-eyed visage casting enchanted comfort and assurance. She's a cult leader, harnessing an offbeat uncanny charisma built up by Billy's awe of her. He says repeatedly that she's "different" and "sees things differently," dancing around terms like "neurodivergent" to a suspicious extent, demonstrating her inability to react to and understand normal human behaviors most keenly when Fielder forces her to watch Abbot and Costello's famed "Who's on First?" routine; she's apparently incapable of articulating any aspect of their skit that is humorous, though she finds it endearing.

Perhaps that's what makes the story worth retelling, and why she's compelling even to the point of her comeuppance: she's a tragic Greek hero, haunting us with her hope even as she infuriates us with her faults. Is her weird, robotic personal signature of not blinking all a performance, or is it really her? Does she exist somewhere beyond the world of regular people? If she were a man, would we think of her the same way? More to the point: is she, indeed, a woman of power who likes to be controlled at home? Or is she rather the master manipulator, using the men around her (like Billy, of course, but also Sunny and other men from her past like Ian Gibbons) as shields and scapegoats for her crimes? Even Fielder gets caught up in her orbit, with a couple moments furtively suggesting that he's perhaps even developing a romantic crush on her. 

This is a three-hour film. And I've only really told you about the first half of it. At almost exactly the 90-minute mark, the entire film changes dramatically and becomes something else entirely. I'm hesitant to spoil it, because I truly think it's a work of inspired, metafictional genius that is best experienced raw. So I'll talk a little about it, but will be brief:

We flash ahead two years, suddenly, and Holmes is snug in prison. Billy is in Texas raising their two kids and posing as Holmes online as he desperately tries to keep her company going. And all of a sudden, Fielder is seated with Amanda Seyfried, who of course deservedly won an Emmy for her career-best performance as Elizabeth Holmes in The Dropout. Her somewhat jarring presence is explained soon enough: she's meant to reenact scenes between Fielder and Holmes that were not captured on camera, including their initial meeting. The meta-awareness kicks into high gear as we watch Seyfried watching Holmes watching Seyfried playing Holmes (in an earlier scene, suggestively staged on Holmes's bed with Fielder and Billy with her, they watch The Dropout before Holmes dissolves into tears and stops them). 

Christopher Abbott is brought in as Billy in these scenes, and seeing the actors flawlessly become the real people we've been watching is arguably even more powerful than Seyfried's performance in the miniseries. Actors will study this film -- particularly its second half -- in classes for years to come. Surprisingly, though, Seyfried becomes a major force in the documentary itself as herself, and this is where the film really blew me away. Seeing the actor dive back into her amazing character is great, but so is getting to know the real Seyfried as a person who's become engrossed in this insane real-life crime story just like us. I say "real," but it's of course possible and even likely that this was a performed version of Seyfried. Curiously, though, I don't know that she's always portrayed in the best light: she's combative and judgmental, sometimes even silly when interacting with Holmes and Billy (a notable moment occurs when Holmes, on the phone, speaks directly to Seyfried, who reacts in a relatably awkward manner). Then again, Seyfried never feels less than genuine onscreen, which is ironic in a film supposedly about real people and real reactions yet hinges on her performance; she reacted in ways I might have, and seeing oneself onscreen like that pulls at one's gray matter.

There will always be more to say about this amazing film. More than once since viewing it, I've wondered the extent to which Oppenheim specifically made it feel like Hitchcock's Vertigo, both in content and in visual and aural style. I certainly hope it gets all the awards this year; it's a rare piece of filmmaking that works subliminally and subtly, best in its moments of sheer, boring mundanity that reveal the glitches in our matrix. It demonstrates that art, perhaps even more than journalism, has the capacity to provide curiosity and meaning even without hard facts and revelations and even truth. Where is truth? What is real, after all? Surely not everything we're seeing.

A close-up of Elizabeth Holmes smiling, with a blurred view of Nathan Fielder in the background

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Undertone (2026)

Score: 2 / 5

Loss of hearing is a minor trope in survival horror, when home invaders or alien monsters are drawn with murderous intent to the sounds someone makes. Like the protagonists in Hush, Don't Breathe, and A Quiet Place, the audience is invited to lean in and remain silent, often holding our breath as we, too, fear detection. This storytelling device is rarely used inversely, though, when we desperately need to hear something in order to understand the plot itself. A notable example -- the only one I can recall offhand -- is The Vast of Night, in which kids use switchboards and phones and radios to learn about an active encounter of the third kind. When A24 announced a new horror film based on aural frisson, I was intrigued to say the least.

Undertone, helmed by a debut director in Ian Tuason, is a devilish little nightmare of a film that seeks to capitalize on its sound design. Set in the home of young woman Evy (Nina Kiri, The Handmaid's Tale), caring for her dying mother, the story follows her experiences of taking a break from being a nursemaid to podcast with her remote friend Justin (Adam DiMarco, The White Lotus). They're a sort of gender-copied Mulder and Scully; their "Undertone Podcast" dives into spooky shenanigans and paranormal activities, wherein Justin advocates and Evy skepticizes. So when Justin receives an email with ten audio recordings from a married couple who start hearing things in their house (it's all a la Paranormal Activity), he introduces it to Evy as their next mystery to unfold on air. Do we call podcasts "on air"? Someone help me out, I'm not a listener.

I say the film seeks to capitalize on its sound design because of this very premise. Once the characters -- of whom we only ever see Evy -- dive into these surely virus-ridden email attachments, I expected some killer sound design meant to disorient and terrify us. Oddly enough, it feels like the filmmakers either didn't know how to do it or thought their material was more interesting narratively. Sure, there are some weird sounds and creepy voices akin to a possessed Regan MacNeil, but nothing particularly scary about sound itself carries the film. Once I wondered if the film would take a turn like in Talk Radio (1988) or Black Christmas (1974) and have the audio messages somehow be recorded inside the house or by a stalker lying in wait. Because other than that potentiality, not much of interest happens with the otherwise striking decision to limit the protagonist (and, thus, the audience) to the desk of a podcaster. 

Then again, not much of interest happens in the film anyway. A rather boring story, to my mind, cuddles more than grapples its primary theme of grief, lulling us into a stupor with cinematography that rarely earns its painfully slow pace. On par with the speed of Skinamarink, this doesn't even have the added pleasures of sheer weirdness and evocative visual nostalgia. As -- spoiler alert, I guess -- they listen through the recordings and reveal some demonic entity in the files, Evy begins to lose her mind and her world fractures. Admittedly the film surprised me a bit in Evy's character, who is more complex than you might at first suppose; she's pregnant and likely considering abortion, her mother is catatonic and dying just upstairs, and the house is littered with religious imagery. Fun themes of faith and death flit in and out, though the screenplay -- also by Tuason -- doesn't really do anything with them. And the plot itself is largely derived from other works like Last Shift (2014) and Malum (2023).

That's not to say it's not entertaining, of course! Just disappointing, especially when the film so easily could have been designed with more aesthetic cohesion. Enhance the soundscape, for starters, and try minimizing the visuals. Develop a more original story that hinges on sound and make us work to understand what's happening. And for goodness' sake, if you're going to use a demon's name, make it recognizable or at least spell it out at some point. I couldn't make much sense of the dialogue in this film. It also didn't help that Justin's character is terribly written; his dialogue often makes little sense and serves only as annoyance. The performance, too, felt off, and I wondered repeatedly if they recast his role. 

I'll go so far as to say it might be the first film that would be better viewing at home as long as you're using surround sound or a pair of excellent headphones; that might improve my opinion on a rewatch. But between a familiar but cool premise and some ugly filmmaking, Undertone simply fails to make much of an impression. 

It's perhaps telling, as a final note, that Blumhouse has already named Tuason as the director of their upcoming Paranormal Activity reboot (or whatever it will be). You can see clear elements of that in play here, with slow, sweeping looks into the dark recesses of Evy's house and compelling use of negative space and stillness in blocking. One expects to see a similar approach to new entries in the famed found footage franchise, though it feels more contrived and artistic in the current age of "elevated" horror. If Undertone is an indication of Tuason's sole aesthetic, we'll be getting more of this unfortunately typical style soon in the franchise made famous for its clever, understated horror. 

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Clayface (2026)

Score: 3.5 / 5

A revenge thriller that uses body horror? It may not be the most original idea, but it's a welcome entry in the superhero genre; I've enjoyed the Sony-produced Marvel films about antiheroes for this reason, but this time we're getting it from DC. Their newly rebooted cinematic universe has so far only included Superman and Supergirl, making Clayface easily the most unexpected and exciting choice of the new franchise. He's not the most familiar character to me personally -- I vaguely remember him from the Gotham series on FOX in the last decade -- so this film works quite well as an origin story. Unfortunately, because of that, the film also feels too predictable and safe, despite its icky body horror. 

Matt Hagen (a dedicated and electrifying Tom Rhys Harries) is the newest leading male in Hollywood: handsome, doing the press circuit, and getting nominated for his first Oscar. In his pride and arrogance, he goes out to celebrate and ends up dancing with the sexiest woman in one of Gotham's crime-ridden clubs. After taking her home, ignoring the advice from his best friend that she's a regular of a local kingpin, he gets caught by said underworld boss. The criminal takes vengeance by carving up Matt's pretty face and paying off any attempts of legal action. Matt's life is over: professionally and romantically, he's doomed, to say nothing of the medical debt he accrues through multiple restorative surgeries that leave him intact but numb and debilitatingly scarred.

The screenplay by notable writers Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini (The Two Faces of January, Drive, Snow White and the Huntsman) focuses in perhaps too tightly to Matt's predicament and desperation to get his own life back. It's a convenient approach that elides much reference to his material limitations and allows Matt to do whatever he wants without much at stake. Granted, his life gets fully taken from him in a few brutal swings: his embezzling manager (Eddie Marsan) and opportunistic best friend (Joshua James) take Matt's professional life and make it their own after Matt's agent dumps him. In a stroke of luck -- and not unlike what we've seen in many superhero movies -- Matt discovers a fringe scientist who has developed nanocell tech to heal grievous scars and wounds. Anyone with any sense knows how this is going to go, even with Naomi Ackie giving an earnest and surprisingly emotionally resonant performance.

Seemingly returned to normal, Matt makes a surprise triumphant appearance at a red carpet event. Before long, though, his heightened emotional state causes his face to melt and he hurries back to the lab to inject himself with a major dose of the healing nano-goo. The good doctor objects but is overruled, and Matt becomes a sort of Cronenbergian protagonist a la The Fly, allowing his newfound powers of shapeshifting to empower him to take revenge on everyone who has wronged him. In this, it's as satisfying as any revenge thriller, with the added benefit of some gruesome and nasty body horror. 

Unfortunately, the film hints a few times at more complex directions it could have explored before reverting to its basic and predictable path. I'd have liked a bit more of the internal psychology of Matt explored: was he always a murderous sociopath, or is this new? Is he being controlled by the cure, an embodied AI-fueled possession like in Upgrade or even The Hands of Orlac? Is his reluctant doctor to blame, like a Victor Frankenstein, or part of a shadowy organization like in The Substance? Not so. Instead, we waste time with the basic plot contrivance of a lone cop (Max Minghella) tracing the series of murders to Matt and building a case against him. 

I felt invited to participate in the film's characters' considerations of just how much Matt is to blame for his killing streak, but by the film's final act, he became increasingly difficult to understand or believe. Arguably it's because his sins have changed him into a monster, but I wanted him to have really earned it as he turns on his only friends in increasingly cruel ways. It just felt convenient that he became such a villain. If this film had taken on the more complex psychological character-driven approach, like Joker, notably, Matt would feel more realized as a compelling antihero while earning our attention. Instead, the film relies on its concept and spectacle to arouse our interest. To be fair, its practical effects are pretty awesome and the gore is considerable indeed. But for a film meant to take place in Gotham, it feels generally too sanitized, too standard, and too safe to be especially memorable.

A partial face of a man, of which the right side is red, and the side melts to form a sculpture of a city with a man in a hoodie walking behind it.

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Whalefall (2026)

Score: 4 / 5

The biblical story of Jonah meets a survival horror adventure like All is Lost in Whalefall, adapted from the excellent novel of the same name by Daniel Kraus. Kraus co-wrote this screenplay with director Brian Duffield (director of No One Will Save You and writer of Underwater, two other high-intensity descents into hell with surprising emotional centers), and the pair capture all the memorable beats of the story while shifting focus slightly from the psychological race against time in the dark, as depicted in the novel, to somewhat greater visual splendor than I'd have thought possible. 

After his father commits suicide by strapping weights to his body and stepping off a boat into the notoriously dangerous waters of Monastery Beach in California, his adult son Jay makes the terrible choice to dive down for his father's remains. Even a bone, he seems to think, will help give his family -- including his mother (Elisabeth Shue) and sisters (Jane Levy and Emily Rudd) -- closure, as the funeral required an empty casket. It's a ludicrous idea, because after a year, it seems unlikely anything but bones could be found anyway, but that's what Jay is after. So he takes an oxygen tank and wades into the water for an unauthorized dive. Nobody even knows he's there, and he's hiding from the authorities because the beach is off-limits today. He even forgot his gloves.

Once in the water, Jay scrounges through the kelp forest until he comes to the sheer drop-off into the submarine canyon that separates Santa Cruz from Monterey. While descending, before long, he encounters a giant squid and its natural predator, a sperm whale, which in their cat-and-mouse chase end up grabbing Jay. He's devoured by the whale along with the squid. Trapped in its gullet, Jay has to try and problem-solve his way out of the literal mouth of death before he runs out of oxygen. 

The film is a gruesome one, and anyone with a queasy stomach may want to take caution. Most of the runtime is excessively wet, with blood, stomach acid, and other assorted goo constantly shining amongst the seawater. Claustrophobic cinematography centers on Jay as he's constantly assaulted by the muscled walls of the whale's internal organs, which periodically contract around him, attempting to chew him so he can pass into its stomach proper. Out of necessity, the production design requires light in this set, so the filmmakers make the choice to keep things perhaps too-well-lit, using the idea of bioluminescent residue from the whale's food, presumably, to make the experience visually dynamic. I found it to be a bit much, but I don't know how else they could have shot most of these scenes. Similarly, when Jay makes it into the whale's stomach in one scene, the ominous glowing yellow of its acid makes for a really effective and upsetting switch. 

Similarly, the limited but increasing shots of the whale's exterior showcase some truly eye-popping visual effects that enhance the story while arguably ruining much of the film's claustrophobic effect. The one exception I'd identify is when the whale gets attacked by orcas, just before the film's climax. The exterior shots of the whale get drained of color, almost to black and white, and the whale floats alone in the deep void. When it sends out sonar signals, we see the feedback in the form of orcas swooping in and out of proximity, chasing down their prey. It's a fascinating and beautiful choice, visually, even if it doesn't quite make sense biologically. And that's why the film works so well!

Of course, in addition to the survival horror of the story, we get lengthy flashbacks in Jay's mind as he struggles to maintain hope and sanity. These take up perhaps more time than expected, but they are absolutely worth the time. Most involve Jay's relationship with his father, Mitt (Josh Brolin), who spends most of their time together being emotionally and verbally abusive to his son; one telling scene also involves physical abuse, and it's hinted that there was much more of this. Mitt's hard on Jay for multiple reasons, but expressly to prepare his only son to be a hardened man who is ready for anything. Jay recalls certain messages just as he needs to remember certain things Mitt taught him in his youth about diving and about the ocean, and at first it feels a bit trite. But the film eventually earns these moments as we dive deeper into their relationship.

And that's Jay's journey as well. The closure he needs isn't based on finding his father's bones; it's about finding his father's essence and learning to appreciate certain aspects of his father. So when, by the film's climax, he begins hearing his father's voice from the whale's bowels -- is it his memory, the whale, God, or indeed his father? -- it no longer matters if Jay has completely lost his grip on sanity or not. He's reached a place, finally, of communication with a healing power outside himself. Austin Abrams -- in his second movie this year vying against tentacled horrors and voracious consumption -- grounds the film with an amazing performance that is, frankly, mostly physical and nonverbal. He grunts and screams and cries his way through fleshy innards and various juices while being crushed and stabbed and burned and broken. 

And that's what makes this film such a satisfying watch and, I suspect, rewatch. Its high-concept premise and massive budget make it a bona fide blockbuster, but it's also fairly subversive in delivery, forcing us to chew on its grander ideas long after we've enjoyed its thrills and spectacle. Some of the viewing experience made me feel out-of-body, too, and the film seems intentionally hinting at that, like with the orca chase or squid fight: these are alien worlds and kaiju-like monsters with no concern for the lone human caught amongst them. Similarly, as our mind deteriorates with Jay's -- like something Lovecraftian -- we're meant to empathize with him, seeing the trap into which he's led himself and how all things, including his memory, have forced him into such a victimized place, both mentally and bodily. 

Whalefall has got a lot on its mind, and it will surely spark some amazing discussions in biological, theological, and therapeutic circles even above and beyond anyone appreciating it for its unique and visionary entertainment value. By the time Brolin explains, in flashback, what exactly a whalefall is -- when a whale's corpse settles and creates a whole new ecosystem for smaller deep-sea creatures -- the film's various thematic interests finally coalesce into a fabulous tapestry interested in purgatorial trauma meant to heal and provide new life.

The poster shows a scuba diver being chased by a sperm whale.

Friday, October 30, 2026

Other Mommy (2026)

Score: 4 / 5

Rob Savage returns to the helm with a fantasy horror like we've never seen. 

The tricky thing about adaptations is that, while the film needs to be accessible to new audiences unfamiliar with its premise, it should also please fans of the source material. It may deviate wildly but still honor the main ideas and sensation of the source, in a case like The Lord of the Rings, for an example of virtually everyone being pleased. Not everyone loves horror novels, and so I can imagine that much of the profound artistry in adapting Other Mommy from its source material will escape casual audiences as a result. Yet, thankfully, Savage's film is strong enough to merit its own discussion without this being a book-vs-film comparison. 

Suffice to say that Josh Malerman's terrifying Incidents Around the House makes for great cinematic material. Told as a haunted house story that becomes a possession story from the perspective of a seven-year-old girl, it accomplishes a rare feat in (mostly) convincingly putting us in a child's shoes and mindset while the unthinkable happens around her. One might think of Paul Tremblay's A Head Full of Ghosts as a counterpoint, or last year's Good Boy. What's remarkable is how satisfying it is to study not just the supernatural but also the mundane from the child's perspective: we learn much about her parents and their troubled marriage in snippets, filtered through the mind of an innocent who doesn't understand things like infidelity and yearning and spoiled dreams and family lies. 

Savage, in adapting the material with writer Nathan Elston, works hard to keep that feeling of us being locked into young Bela's perspective. The camera -- handled masterfully by Lowell A. Meyer -- is constantly in motion, swirling and zooming around gorgeous sets with a sort of childlike wonder. Shots are often shot from waist level on an adult, roughly the height for a child's head, sometimes even tilting up at adult faces. Certain details of the haunting, including balloons and colorful plastic balls and plastic partyware, are multiplied to silly extremes to generate a sensation of fantasy unusual in the genre. The demonic entity known as Other Mommy is often rendered in grotesque CGI not unlike the visual stylizations in IT and its sequel. These choices -- even the setting of Grandma's house on a stunning Gothic cliff -- create a sort of out-of-body sensation in the attentive viewer that I found hard to shake afterward.

A potential drawback of this perspective is that we don't really get a lot of story here. At least not as much as many viewers might want. We have to piece together aspects of the parents' private life from snippets of somewhat contrived conversations and filtered through Bela's haphazard attention. A key moment takes place early on when Bela's mother is being comforted by her father's best friend; we see the intimate affection and realize they're having an affair in a silent montage as Bela spins on a tire swing several yards away. In this way, the film rewards viewers who focus, sidestepping the increasingly annoying problem of screenplays overexplaining themselves to distracted audiences. We also sometimes get bizarre time jumps via edits, which upon a repeat viewing I appreciated more: this editing style helps create the childlike fantasy logic of the film, shifting unexpectedly and without warning, cutting out the boring bits and dwelling on the indeed strange incidents around Bela. 

Much like Malerman's novel, the film's pace is reckless. One of its unique charms is that it wastes no time getting spooky. There's no buildup to the haunting; we are launched in medias res and before very long both parents are completely convinced of the supernatural entity attempting to possess their daughter. So they do the Chris MacNeil thing and try doctors and priests to fix things, right? Wrong. They go on the run to other houses while trying to figure out what to do. It's a really cool narrative choice, as it creates a mythic journey out of their plight while multiplying their problems (like sleep deprivation and endangering their other loved ones). 

But, led by a masterful performance from Jessica Chastain and some nice work from Jay Duplass, young Arabella Olivia Clark carries the film like a pro. The relationships between these characters -- and their histories -- feel organic and lived-in, comfortable and loaded with nonverbal weight in their glances as they struggle to shield Bela from the darker aspects of adult life. And, even with the sometimes jarringly surreal appearances by Other Mommy threatening to derail our suspension of disbelief, they keep the increasingly bizarre visuals grounded through their dedicated, wonderfully realistic performances. 

I'd love to wax poetic about every aspect of this film, from its satisfyingly overwrought symbolism to its incredible centerpiece of a high-tech seance a la Insidious, and of course to its ending which is different than but on par with the novel's, because it's just one of those that feel tailored to me, you know? Similar to Coraline in a lot of ways, the material embraces its strange attractiveness and invites us to enjoy some legitimately creepy domestic terrors. It thrillingly honors its brilliant source material and offers surprisingly unique artistic inspiration to boot, all while making for a hell of a ride. 

In red monochrome, Other Mommy (Jessica Chastain) stands in the middle of a room, framed by a doorway, with both her hands raised up.

Sense and Sensibility (2026)

Score: 2 / 5

Another year, another Jane Austen adaptation. Unfortunately, this year's theatrical feature is something less than memorable. Georgia Oakley's grounded and tactile vision for Sense and Sensibility offers a few notable pleasures -- it will surely do well among Austen apologists and completionists -- but even as I walked out of the theater I found my mind drifting wildly and unable to remember much of what I'd just seen. Admittedly, the material is perhaps my least favorite of Austen's novels in terms of plot, characterization, and theming, mostly because it's always felt underbaked to me, as if it was a parable Austen attempted to flesh out.

As an adaptation, this film delivers the source material into the arguably more palatable form of just over two hours' experience. Centering, of course, on the eldest Dashwood sisters, the story concerns Elinor and Marianne as they, their mother, and their younger sister are ousted from their home, penniless after the death of their patriarch. Their brother has "rightly" inherited the estate, and he and his pitiless wife waste no time in claiming what's newly theirs. Their only hope, upon moving to Barton Cottage in Devonshire, is to marry well despite their low status. We follow their encounters with various suitors; Elinor, more reserved and thoughtful, attempts to overcome social boundaries and expectations with her sister-in-law's respectable elder brother Edward, while passionate and melodramatic Marianne burns brightly with charismatic but dubious Willoughby while the awkward but earnest Colonel Brandon waits patiently for her.

Thankfully, the romantic plots are less the focus of this film than they were of the 1995 film. Rather, Oakley and her team work hard to make this film feel palpably realistic, grounded and dirty to the point of highlighting dresses stained with berry juice and hair getting tangled in the breeze. More like Hamnet in that regard, we're treated frequently to wordless moments of the sisters cuddling in bed together, wandering the woods, and practicing housework in their smaller new digs. The actors are all fine (including Daisy Edgar-Jones and George MacKay), but the interest here is really the visuals; Fiona Shaw is the notable standout as the generous busybody Mrs. Jennings, who mobilizes the sisters' social efforts in several hilarious scenes that smartly let her chew all she wants. 

It's a diverting enough viewing experience, especially if you like such things. I just found myself wondering repeatedly -- both during the screening and now -- why this piece exists at all, and I still can come up with no answer.