Score: 5 / 5
The most important film of the year, You Can See Everything does wholly new things with the documentary form. Any attempt to render this viewing experience into prose will lessen its physical and psychic impact, so be warned. If you want a singular cinematic rapture this year, go to your nearest cinema while this is still available on the big screen.
And I'll start sharing my thoughts by admitting that I was wrong.
Not about Nathan Fielder, of whom I knew literally nothing, and not about Lance Oppenheim, whose Primetime is possibly my favorite film of 2026. No, I was baffled by why anyone thought yet another documentary about Elizabeth Holmes was even necessary, much less for a studio like A24 to back it. HBO's The Inventor (2019) already exists, along with books, podcasts, interviews, write-ups, and of course the dramatized miniseries The Dropout. Surely we could learn nothing new about her or her crimes, bizarre and inexplicable as they are. Why, then, do we need to exist with her in her own home in the month before she begins her 11-year prison sentence?
Watch, and learn, young grasshopper.
Yet Fielder himself is truly the main character in this film; its main themes not about family or loss or even crime, but rather about the nature of reality and those strange people who live on a different wavelength than the rest of us. Fielder's hero's quest launches him on a search for truth, or at least some kind of truth. He's no journalist, and ethics become a primary concern as things evolve between him and his hosts. Hosts, I say, because apparently Holmes had reached out to A24 specifically -- a suspect choice, for several reasons -- to invite a filmmaker to come live with her and film the experience. How much could possibly be true under such circumstances? Yet, later, when it's revealed that, during their initial meeting, Fielder straight up asked for some compensation if the film does well, the filmmakers' reactions are almost exaggeratedly shocked that he would ask for such a reasonable thing. Again, they're not journalists, and that's not where the shady ethics stop in this film.
Fielder often approaches scenes with Holmes and her husband Billy with a deadpan, sardonic expression; I've learned since that this tends to be his persona, but here I found it distracting more than humorous. This despite uproarious laughter from the audience in each screening I've attended, which is understandable but feels a bit tasteless to me, considering her impending separation from family. Yet the reaction is undeniable at certain moments, such as when Billy clearly wants to be filmed while showered; the full frontal is always nice, but here it feels especially insidious as we begin to learn more about Fielder's hosts. Not particularly potent, Fielder tends to stalk and skulk around like a serial killer in the making; often leering out of doorways or creeping from his car window, he's shown to be a physically unpleasant presence and, increasingly, an unreliable narrator. By film's end, he's done some overtly unethical things in pursuit of whatever truth he seeks, to the point of changing his own dramatization to be less impactful and to the further point of lying to us -- his audience -- about going into the water on the beach with Holmes. Is he emphasizing Holmes's hypnotic power and showing how fallible he himself is? Then again, is he just making a point to us not to blindly believe anything, even what we see in his documentary?
The three main characters, together, make the film's dynamics oddly like a horror-comedy, scored as they are by an ominous musical undergird. Billy is monstrous and awful. He lords over the film like a despotic villain, so egregiously controlling every moment he's nearby that the film can't help but show his behind-the-scenes "directing." He domineers the home, even roughly taking over beating her eggs because she's not doing it right (whatever that even means). If Holmes says something that could be taken as less-than-innocent, Billy halts the proceedings and makes necessary adjustments. Despite their claims of transparency, he repeatedly separates himself from the film crew and takes Holmes along so they can reassess their tactics. This latter is where the film's title presumably comes from: after some initial engagement, Billy takes off down the beach, where Holmes soon texts Fielder that he and his crew "can see everything," an oddly removed moment of what sounds like blanket consent. It's hard to accept that this isn't determined by Billy, but then, it is Holmes texting it. Later in the film, when Holmes is in prison, Billy uses her name and social media platform to pose as Holmes herself; they claim it's with her full consent, but what he posts is a far cry from how she sounds.
Which brings us to Holmes herself. While the film formally seems angled to get us to see Billy for the absuive manipulator and narcissist that he clearly is, it does so by somewhat softening Holmes's impact. One wonders the extent to which Fielder was beguiled by the cipher of a woman who never seems fully present or aware. Granted, she's trying to coddle her children and partner in the limited time she has before incarceration, so who's to say any of us would be fully in command of our faculties? Yet along with her near-constant rocking of a baby, she too is putting up a lot of smoke and mirrors. She comes off -- and I think this is crucial and perhaps the most disturbing part of this film -- remarkably well here. Surprisingly little time is devoted to her life, her crimes, and her interior life, so don't go into a screening expecting a tell-all.
Rather, if we see the real Holmes at all -- whoever that is, and however we might determine when we see it -- it is through a glass darkly, at best. She's often framed with a beatific smile in warm amber light, a consummate mother and housewife holding fast to her idealism and bizarre sense of hope. She wants her company to continue and thrive, pivoting as they are now to deepfakes and AI (which elicited such a loud "no fucking way" from me in the theater that other people chimed in to repeat variations), and she won't give an inch regarding her claims to innocence. Though I wish a hard-hitting journalist was called in instead, Fielder occasionally fires a blunt question at her, and her abilities of evasion and blatant lying is as admirable as it is terrifying.
And that gets at the heart of this movie, and why her story is so compelling in general. Her entire basis for "not guilty" is semantics -- her intended technology is possible, just not happening yet -- and her desperation to hold on to hope and intention and purpose is relatable. Which leads us to perhaps the most important question of all: what is her goal in allowing these documentarians into her private life during perhaps the most important and vulnerable month of her life? To be humanized in the public eye? If so, I think she succeeds in disturbingly effective form, playing the filmmakers and audience like a harp. She plucks the strings with nary a fumble, allowing Billy to come off like a Mad Men antagonist and Fielder to seem like a simpering fool, all the while gazing into space like Cate Blanchett's Galadriel, a preternatural, wide-eyed visage casting enchanted comfort and assurance. She's a cult leader, harnessing an offbeat uncanny charisma built up by Billy's awe of her. He says repeatedly that she's "different" and "sees things differently," dancing around terms like "neurodivergent" to a suspicious extent, demonstrating her inability to react to and understand normal human behaviors most keenly when Fielder forces her to watch Abbot and Costello's famed "Who's on First?" routine; she's apparently incapable of articulating any aspect of their skit that is humorous, though she finds it endearing.
Perhaps that's what makes the story worth retelling, and why she's compelling even to the point of her comeuppance: she's a tragic Greek hero, haunting us with her hope even as she infuriates us with her faults. Is her weird, robotic personal signature of not blinking all a performance, or is it really her? Does she exist somewhere beyond the world of regular people? If she were a man, would we think of her the same way? More to the point: is she, indeed, a woman of power who likes to be controlled at home? Or is she rather the master manipulator, using the men around her (like Billy, of course, but also Sunny and other men from her past like Ian Gibbons) as shields and scapegoats for her crimes? Even Fielder gets caught up in her orbit, with a couple moments furtively suggesting that he's perhaps even developing a romantic crush on her.
This is a three-hour film. And I've only really told you about the first half of it. At almost exactly the 90-minute mark, the entire film changes dramatically and becomes something else entirely. I'm hesitant to spoil it, because I truly think it's a work of inspired, metafictional genius that is best experienced raw. So I'll talk a little about it, but will be brief:
We flash ahead two years, suddenly, and Holmes is snug in prison. Billy is in Texas raising their two kids and posing as Holmes online as he desperately tries to keep her company going. And all of a sudden, Fielder is seated with Amanda Seyfried, who of course deservedly won an Emmy for her career-best performance as Elizabeth Holmes in The Dropout. Her somewhat jarring presence is explained soon enough: she's meant to reenact scenes between Fielder and Holmes that were not captured on camera, including their initial meeting. The meta-awareness kicks into high gear as we watch Seyfried watching Holmes watching Seyfried playing Holmes (in an earlier scene, suggestively staged on Holmes's bed with Fielder and Billy with her, they watch The Dropout before Holmes dissolves into tears and stops them).
Christopher Abbott is brought in as Billy in these scenes, and seeing the actors flawlessly become the real people we've been watching is arguably even more powerful than Seyfried's performance in the miniseries. Actors will study this film -- particularly its second half -- in classes for years to come. Surprisingly, though, Seyfried becomes a major force in the documentary itself as herself, and this is where the film really blew me away. Seeing the actor dive back into her amazing character is great, but so is getting to know the real Seyfried as a person who's become engrossed in this insane real-life crime story just like us. I say "real," but it's of course possible and even likely that this was a performed version of Seyfried. Curiously, though, I don't know that she's always portrayed in the best light: she's combative and judgmental, sometimes even silly when interacting with Holmes and Billy (a notable moment occurs when Holmes, on the phone, speaks directly to Seyfried, who reacts in a relatably awkward manner). Then again, Seyfried never feels less than genuine onscreen, which is ironic in a film supposedly about real people and real reactions yet hinges on her performance; she reacted in ways I might have, and seeing oneself onscreen like that pulls at one's gray matter.
There will always be more to say about this amazing film. More than once since viewing it, I've wondered the extent to which Oppenheim specifically made it feel like Hitchcock's Vertigo, both in content and in visual and aural style. I certainly hope it gets all the awards this year; it's a rare piece of filmmaking that works subliminally and subtly, best in its moments of sheer, boring mundanity that reveal the glitches in our matrix. It demonstrates that art, perhaps even more than journalism, has the capacity to provide curiosity and meaning even without hard facts and revelations and even truth. Where is truth? What is real, after all? Surely not everything we're seeing.
