Score: 2 / 5
Rarely, anymore, are entire films carried by a single performance, but Jai Courtney is the Atlas bearing up Dangerous Animals. A mildly clever combination of serial killer and killer shark narratives, the film needs a strong and memorable monster at its core, so we never quite know who might enter, revolve around him, and have to fend off his attacks. His character, Tucker, is the kind of killer we almost like; we can imagine, under the right circumstances, meeting this charismatic guy and wanting to grab a beer and hear his story. He's also a beast hiding in plain sight; unlike sharks -- his favorite animal, and his evidence disposal method -- Tucker selects his victims before there's any blood in the water, disappearing them with callous efficiency. In fact, even his method of reducing stress and putting his prey at ease, disarmed me right off the bat: getting his nervous tourists to breathe and chant, they end up singing "Baby Shark" in aware goofiness. The film opens with one such case in a pseudo-Pyscho-esque focal redirect that sets quite a brutal tone for the film to follow; we learn eventually it is only Tucker's most recent of a long string of crimes.
Courtney manages to evoke a hell of a lot while negotiating a screenplay that doesn't give him the meatiest material. Imposing and confident, Tucker is his own Ahab; despite channeling Robert Shaw in Jaws with some clear parallels, Courtney differentiates his character by making him slightly less articulate and more physical. Like Kathy Bates in Misery or Robert de Niro in Cape Fear, Courtney is truly charming despite -- or perhaps because of -- his brusque personality and quiet moments of internal conflict. Not conflict between right and wrong, no; conflict between self-awareness and masking. These are characters utterly convinced of their rightness in wrongness, yet aware that their murderous designs must be hidden. They use doublespeak and partial-truths, welcoming their prey into an invisible web where, once entangled, they can feast at leisure. On the actor's face, we see shivers that curl the edge of the mouth, that strain the corners of the eye, in those moments of transition between earnestness and deception by omission. The devil is indeed in the details.
Courtney isn't helped much by the rest of the film, however, which feels oddly inert and familiar. The high concept, if you haven't extrapolated, is that Tucker abducts tourists visiting the Gold Coast in Australia, taking them out to go shark cage diving and filming them while they're eaten alive. It's cool enough, and there's some novelty in the first time we see it happen: Tucker lowering the victim into the incarnadine ocean in a harness as sharks swarm. But once that's done, there's little to maintain interest the rest of the film's runtime beyond a few chase scenes around the boat and some consternation about handcuffs, a harpoon gun, a flare, and drugged food. I half-expected Tucker, as he checks on his captive females, to bring them lotion in a basket. Instead, he mostly waxes prosaic about his love of sharks, how he survived a shark attack as a boy, how he views sharks almost as gods; it never feels too talky in the sense of a villainous monologue, but most of it also never comes to fruition. That's because Tucker, no matter his relationship with the sharks, is just a sadist: he films his victims (seemingly mostly women) and cuts off a piece of their hair to keep in the videotapes of his little library.
This isn't necessarily a knock on the film; familiarity doesn't determine a film's entertainment value or success. Sean Byrne is a capable enough director, with The Loved Ones and The Devil's Candy in his filmography, but he does tend toward more lurid material. In fact, he seems like the kind of guy most influenced by '80s and '90s thrillers, and that should have manifested just a bit more here. This story had the potential to lean more into Dead Calm than The Silence of the Lambs, and I wish Byrne had chosen that route. These characters aren't, however, sexualized much -- despite some suggestion -- and this film is less about a psychological war between spider and fly than it is about a series of cat-and-mouse action encounters.
And this was my main problem with the film. Handsomely directed and shot, the film nevertheless falters in increasingly stupid decisions made by its protagonist. Hassie Harrison plays Zephyr, the Girl Who Fights Back, with admirable strength and physicality, certain enough; as written and directed, though, her character infuriates with her refusal to ensure Tucker is dead. She "escapes" several times during this movie, sneaking up on Tucker with various plans to overpower him, and even when she succeeds in an ambush, she then runs off so that he can come to and give chase again. Why does nobody double tap? Or at least tie him up, break his leg, make sure he's knocked out? He's actively torturing you, trying to kill you, and there is no chance someone else can help you. Why don't you fight back?
Its B-movie foundation is never quite shaken, and in that it finds its groove. As an action and/or erotic thriller, Dangerous Animals never quite matters beyond its central conceit; similarly, as a shark horror movie it all but fails. I'm a bit of a shark movie aficionado at this point, and this one mostly treats them with a less-is-more eye that undermines Tucker's worship of them. That fatal flaw in the film's internal logic spoiled it for me in a way it probably won't for most other viewers. Case in point: the climax, when a great white shark finally arrives in an admittedly chilling moment, turns when the shark, having been stabbed by Tucker, appears to choose to not eat Zephyr and opt instead for revenge on Tucker. It's silly and completely took me out of the moment, to say nothing of the rather poor CGI. On the other hand, during some of their chases, Byrne's team seamlessly integrate fight choreography, cinematography, and editing with a finesse and attention to earned violence that we don't even often see in action films. It may be nonsensical in design, but it's well-shot, and that makes it all at least watchable.


